I've definitely read more vampire stories in my life but probably watched more zombie movies. Christopher Pike's The Last Vampire series got me started on them pretty young. I loved when zombie movies started making the zombies fast, added a whole new dimension to their terror. Since the romance genre is what I read the most, werewolves kind of fall into the shifter category and I just don't respond the best to imagining partners as animals.
For other, definitely witches and ghosts, numerous books and movies have been consumed about those beings.
I don't know if anyone watched Being Human (the BBC tv show, never watched the American one), that starred a ghost, vampire, and werewolf?The first three seasons were pretty good.